18 November 2026
Southland now has a defined process for considering its local government future, while uncertainty remains for the rest of New Zealand, says Te Uru Kahika Reform Sponsor and Canterbury Regional Council Chair Dr Deon Swiggs.
Dr Swiggs said the Local Government Commission's draft plan for Southland is a positive contribution to the national conversation about the future of lo cal government because it brings together evidence, regional context, and community involvement, offering lessons for how wider reform should proceed.
"Southlanders have a pathway forward to have their say on an evidence-backed proposed model of local government for their region. The outcome isn't decided, but Southlanders know how that decision will be made and they will part of it," said Dr Swiggs.
"We’re ready to work with the next Government to chart a well-considered way forward for the rest of New Zealand, with central and local government working in partnership and communities at the heart of decisions that will shape their places for decades to come.
“There is a sense of urgency as we prepare to implement a new resource management system that includes regional spatial planning, seek to scale up work to keep more New Zealanders safer from hazards such as flooding, and tackle pest control that supports our primary sector and environmental outcomes.
“We need certainty about the future of local government so we can get on with delivering the services and outcomes our communities depend on," said Dr Swiggs.
The Commission has proposed replacing the regional council and Southland's three city and district councils with a single unitary Southland Council, supported by nine local boards. Southlanders can make submissions until 5 February 2027.
"This is Southland's decision to make, and Te Uru Kahika isn't taking a position on what the right answer is for Southland. That's for Southlanders, through the Commission's process and a poll," Dr Swiggs said, “Our interest is that regional functions stay together and are delivered at regional scale, whatever governance model Southland chooses.”
Dr Swiggs said the Southland process also shows why reform must be informed by the circumstances and needs of individual regions, rather than assuming one model will work everywhere.
"Every region has its own geography, communities, challenges and opportunities. Southland's process shows the value of taking the time to understand those differences and build a proposal around what works for the region."
The Commission's findings add to a growing body of evidence about the scale at which regional services and responsibilities are best delivered. In its draft plan, the Commission states:
"Many of the issues affecting Southland extend beyond individual council boundaries. Environmental management, river catchments, flood protection, biosecurity, emergency management, transport networks and economic development all require coordinated decision-making at a regional scale.”
In Southland, those cross-boundary functions are mostly delivered by Environment Southland for the whole region. Environment Southland Chair Jeremy McPhail said keeping them together at regional scale is the priority, whatever structure Southland settles on.
“Keeping regional functions together means we can retain specialist expertise and regional systems, plan and invest across the whole of Southland, and deploy people and resources where they're most needed.
“It also avoids duplicating capability between organisations or having to rely on agreements and joint arrangements to coordinate services when timely, region-wide decisions are needed,” said Mr McPhail.
Dr Swiggs said this was consistent with the findings of Te Uru Kahika's independently commissioned Grounded report, which found most regional functions work best at regional or catchment scale.
"Reform should start with the outcomes communities need and the scale at which functions work, then build structures around them. Southland is a useful test of that approach."
Dr Swiggs said it was important to be realistic about what reorganisation can deliver.
"The modelling suggests real but modest savings, a little under 2% of operating costs a year. That helps, but structural change on its own won't fix the underlying cost pressures councils face, and nobody should promise ratepayers it will."
Dr Swiggs also said the Local Government Commission's work with Southland councils highlights the importance of central and local government working collaboratively with communities on structural reform.
"The Commission has worked closely with Southland's councils, Te Ao Mārama on behalf of Ngāi Tahu ki Murihiku, and communities across the region to develop a proposal informed by local context. That approach should be a model for any future local government reorganisation work," said Dr Swiggs.